Your Gateway to Music and More from a Christian Perspective
     Slow down as you approach the gate, and have your change ready....
SubscribeAbout UsFeaturesNewsReviewsMoviesConcert ReviewsTop 10ResourcesContact Us
About Us

Album Reviews
Concert Reviews

Top 10
Contact Us


Poor Old Lu
July 1, 2002
By Matt Modrich
Pictures by Trilisa M. Perrine

Poor Old Lu was one of the coolest “Christian” bands, back in the pre-Tooth and Nail days when Seattle grunge rocked the mainstream. For many fans, their breakup in ’96 was quite saddening, but still their memory has lived on. 

Then, in 2001, after five years of non-existence, one of Christian music’s most beloved bands reunited. Since then Poor Old Lu has been working on a new album, which is scheduled to be released this fall on Tooth and Nail

I recently caught up with Lu vocalist Scott Hunter in Galesburg, Illinois at a pre-Cornerstone Festival concert. The two main subjects were the new album “The Waiting Room” and more importantly, just how good it is for the band to be back together.

Modrich: I was reading an interview with Jesse in which he said that Jeremy Enigk, of Sunny Day Real Estate, was the lead singer of Poor Old Lu along with you for a while. Do you guys still keep in touch with him?

Hunter: It was about in eighth or ninth grade and we were all in a band together. It was Aaron doing basically keyboards and some guitar, Nick doing bass, and Jeremy and I would split the vocals. Jeremy did about two-thirds of the songs. I did about one-third of the songs. We did maybe one performance of that, but it was junior high, kind of early, early high school. But it was a couple of years before any Poor Old Lu stuff. Then, you had a question about keeping in touch with Jeremy. He and Nick grew up together, they went to school together and they were good friends. Aaron and I knew each other and then a couple of years later, Nick and Aaron met up and that’s how Jeremy got in. So [we’re] from different sides, but Nick was always the one who was keeping in touch with Jeremy. But I don’t think he’s talked to him in awhile, I’m not quite sure what he’s up to. 

Modrich: I understand you’ve got a pretty big following on the Internet, especially the message board at Why have the fans kept the Lu memory alive?

Hunter: I kind of stumbled onto that message board late in the game. There was just a core of people who had Poor Old Lu in common just hooking up. They will agree they have a tendency to get off the subject. I come on there and I’ll post a message here and there. And I’ll respond to some of their questions and sometimes they’ll write questions specifically to get me to respond. They’re just a crazy group, but they’re tons of fun and they have good stuff to share. 

Modrich: What have you guys been up to musically and otherwise since the band broke up?

Hunter: Late 1996 we quit doing stuff. 1997 through 2001, I wasn’t doing anything musically per se. I was doing stuff at church with worship, but that was about it. Aaron had been doing Rose Blossom and had been doing his solo stuff. Nick had also been playing with Aaron in Rose Blossom and playing in some other projects. Jesse had been doing World Inside, and helping out with Morella’s Forest and other bands like that. And then, in late 2000, we started talking pretty seriously about wanting to do something again. Agreeing that if we waited too long, people weren’t going to care anymore. So in March 2001, we had reunion shows, played Cornerstone last year and some other festivals, and had a really good time. And then after that, [we] settled down to start doing an album. [We’ve] been doing that for a while and we just finished that up last week. 

Modrich: What made you link with Tooth and Nail? You were on Alarma in the pre-Tooth and Nail days. 

Hunter: All the labels that we were on before, starting with Frontline, Alarma and moving to KMG moving to something else, they’re all gone. And we wouldn’t want to resign anything with them anyhow. We were looking for a deal that we could do just one record for now. [We were looking for a label] that would understand where we’re coming from. We want to do another album. We would like it to sell well and we will support it to a point, but we’re not going to do elaborate tours. We have other stuff going on, so it’s hard to get too crazy. And we’ve known Brandon for a long time, from Frontline, from Alarma. [We] just started talking with him and he gave us some of the benefits that we were looking for. Out of the whole deal, they’ve been really good to work with actually. 

Modrich: What do you think was the biggest reason the band broke up? Were artistic differences an issue?

Hunter: I don’t know, maybe all the guys would say something different. But I think at the time, it was just the time to do it. Aaron especially was looking for some different outlets artistically. We started so young and even up until the time we broke up, we were very young even though we had put out however many CDs and had done quite a bit. It was just kind of time and it was a hard decision to make for everybody. It wasn’t like one person was like “Forget it!” and everybody else was crying. We made the decision and stuck with it. Like I said, years later, five years down the road or however long it was, we realized that we wanted to do another project and that we had to do it or not do it.

Modrich: What have you heard from Poor Old Lu fans about getting back together and what has the anticipation been like for this new album? 

Hunter: Our normal fan base is really excited about it because they want to hear something new from us, because it’s been so long. We really have a large fan base that has gotten into Poor Old Lu since we broke up in ’96. A lot of people that started hearing about us, in ’97, ’98 and ’99 or whatever, from friends and picking up [an] album. I think it’s kind of exciting for them, because a lot of people got into Poor Old Lu then found out that we broke up and of course they’re really bummed. As far as the buzz around the new thing, I haven’t personally heard a lot of real specific stuff. People are just like, “Hey, I want to hear the new stuff.” But I don’t know if there’s some doubt. People just want to hear it and see what Poor Old Lu can do after six years.

Modrich: The biggest question I have is: Is Poor Old Lu emo now?

Hunter: Are we emo? You know, I’m the lousiest person to ask because I don’t really even know what emo is.

Modrich: You had Jeremy Enigk.

Hunter: Yeah. If you listen to our past albums one of the things that’s fairly consistent, if anything is consistent about our music, is that we change quite a bit throughout the course of an album. You’ve got some songs that are a bit darker and some songs that are happier. You’ve got usually a funky song on there. Probably the album that’s the most consistent is Sin and it’s not very consistent. I think it’s been hard to ever put us in a genre because we don’t stick with super-heavy stuff, we don’t stick with real downbeat stuff; we just kind of do whatever. It’s one of the reasons people like listening to Poor Old Lu, because there’s always kind of a different song. 

Modrich: So for the record, “No, you’re not emo?”

Hunter: I’d say no.

Modrich: How long have you guys been working on this upcoming album? What is it called?

Hunter: The album is called The Waiting Room. I think we started working on it about ten months ago. Last September (2001) we started working on it and then just finished it up at the end of June 2002. Now we weren’t working on it straight. We worked for a week here and a few days here, and then did most of the work in probably March and May/June of this year, definitely did more of the work in late or mid-2002.

Modrich: What’s a preview of what this should be like compared to past albums?

Hunter: I was trying to think of which album of ours you would compare it to and I couldn’t come up with anything. In a lot of ways it’s probably closest to Eighth Wonder, our last real [album], because it’s definitely more produced than say Sin. The songs are more constructed, more put together. It’s just too hard to call. Our sound is all over the place and we just do whatever. 

Modrich: What do you like about this new album, what are some of the highlights?

Hunter: There are a few of the songs on there that are the best we’ve ever written. The title track on the album, is the very last song on the album; it’s about five and a half minutes long. It’s pretty cool-it’s got a nice feel to it. It’ll be a fun one to play live. It starts off with a bang and makes some nice transitions.

Modrich: Have you grown since you were last in the studio? What things have become sharper or progressed?

Hunter: One of the things that Aaron has been doing over the last five/six years is a lot of producing, a lot of engineering and so his ear is very different than [it] used to be. He has the producer’s mind when he’s doing albums and when he was doing ours. I listen to music a lot more now than I used, I think all of us in the band do, so listening to the album, we notice things a lot more than we did before. We notice when a background vocal is lacking. We notice when something needs to build a bit more. We notice when something cuts off too quickly or what the progression of the verse-chorus-verse-chorus should be. We have grown musically and in a number of ways lyrically. There will be some interesting surprises lyrically on the album. Nothing super crazy, but there is a theme running through the album.

Modrich: Is that faith-based or not so much or? 

Hunter: Oh, definitely faith-based, but the name of the album is The Waiting Room. There’s a song called “Now.” There’s a song called “Today.” There’s a song called “A Month of Moments.” There are a number of songs that deal with time. There’s an element of: “What are we doing? What are we waiting for? What are we doing if He appeared now? What have we done with our past? What are we doing with the future?” A lot of time-based stuff and how it relates to our walks in Christ. I don’t claim to ever sit down and be a real genius with writing lyrics. People tend to like them and I give all the credit to the Lord, because I don’t usually remember writing the lyrics. It’s not like I’m possessed or anything, but they just flow. I’m always curious what people find, because people usually find really great stuff that never even came to my mind. I’ll be interested to see what people find.

Modrich: How do you guys feel about music and ministry? What are your views and have they changed since you were last doing the band? 

Hunter: This is one that I probably couldn’t speak on behalf of the whole band. I would have to do my own views. I’m also a high school youth pastor and I see what the kids in my youth group are listening to. I see how that affects them and I take that to heart. There are a number of bands that are pretty flippant about what they’re doing, what they’re saying and how they’re being portrayed in the industry. I’m not pointing fingers or naming names, that’s the Lord convicting their own hearts. I would like people to know that when they listen to Poor Old Lu and when they hear our lyrics, [what] they see is genuine and [is] something that is pointed toward God. Are we super-evangelical? No. Are we doing altar calls? No. But we’re honest, we’re sincere and we love the Lord, and I think the lyrics show that. 

Modrich: At this point what type of commitment is there to the band, and what do you  think the future holds as far as touring and more albums after this one?

Hunter: That’s so hard to say. We just finished this album and that was a pretty long process. I could probably speak on behalf of the whole band. We would like to do another album. We would like to have it be more normal. Jesse was out of town, out of the state, across the country for most of this album and it would be great to have all the guys together. He’ll be moving out to Seattle again in about a month. It’d be great to have all the guys together writing songs, and then going into the studio being able to lay them down. As far as touring, we’re definitely going to play some shows. Especially the fact that Jesse will be out in our area, we’ll be able to play shows more frequently. We don’t have plans of playing every week. I don’t know if we’re going to be able to tour. We would like to do half a dozen shows around the U.S. just to support the album, do some major places and just do some bigger shows. I’m not sure if it’s going to happen or not, but I think we’ll try.

Modrich: Are there any last words, thoughts, comments, suggestions, totally open-ended?

Hunter: It’s been a lot of fun hanging out with these guys again. Since ’96, they were swept out of my life and Poor Old Lu has been able to bring us back together to hang out. Not only to just have fun, because we’re pretty goofy guys, but also spiritually to talk about stuff. To get back in to each other’s lives and say, “Hey, what’s going on? Where do you need to grow?”-because we do have a big impact on each other in a lot of ways.

Matt Modrich is also acontributing writer to



 Copyright © 1996 - 2002 The Phantom Tollbooth