James Taylor  
Great Woods  
Mansfield, MA  
June 3, 1998  
Approximately 2 1/2 hours.  
 
Why a review of James Taylor for The Phantom Tollbooth?  Simple.  There are lots of Christians that like James Taylor and we are, after all, The Source for music reviews of interest to Christians. This naturally begs the question: why do so many Christians count themselves as James Taylor fans?  I can think of two reasons.  First of all, his music is benign and safe.  Christians like benign and safe.  Most Christians don't like scary and questionable, and James Taylor is never scary and rarely questionable.  In fact, given his penchant for being safe and rarely questionable, there is assuredly a contingent of our family that has assumed James Taylor must be of the faith.  See also the fans of David Wilcox, Collective Soul, Extreme, Dream Theater, Kings X, and even Bob Dylan: artists whose faith in Christ have been much--sometimes hotly and always wastefully--debated.  
 
Second, and most importantly, there is a thematic quality to James Taylor's music that resonates with "believers."  In Taylor's own words his songs are largely about "moving from darkness to light, about regeneration, emerging and transformation, and consolation."  These themes should be of interest to us, because they are a central part of our own stories, the stories of our faith journeys.  James Taylor, be he Christian, Buddhist, pagan, or a worship-our-mother-earth-gaze-some-more-at-your-navel-and-pray-to-the-trees new ager, is still writing wonderful stories of faith, hope, and love.  His recent opening appearance for his current tour was no exception.  

In fact, this particular concert was probably somewhere up near his 4,782nd, give or take a few hundred.  He's been singing, songwriting, and officially releasing albums since 1968, which makes him one of those rare musicians with three decades of experience.  As a result, his cross-generational appeal is abundantly evident.  You'll find two-year olds to eighty-year youngs in attendance, and every age group in between.  James Taylor remains one of our most enduring and prolific American troubadours.  He's also one of the best. This year alone he won two Gramm'ys (Best Pop Album and Best Engineered Album) for his latest album, Hourglass,  which is by all reports the best album he has released since the late Seventies.  More importantly, Bob Dylan, the poet of our generation, at that time named Taylor as one of the songwriters he valued.  Or as James Taylor wrote:  "We can spend a great deal of time mourning our youth.  Or not.  More optimistically, we can see the recent past as having triggered a need to recreate our themes--trick ourselves into being ourselves again, even if we are a folksinger in the electronic age."  
 
Dylan isn't the only fan by far.  You'd be hard pressed to find a more enthusiastic audience than his home-folk outside of Boston.  This North Carolina boy has called Massachusetts his home for years, and New Englandish references fill his songs, generating boisterous shouts of acclamation whenever he utters one.  Yet Taylor's success in these parts is not merely one of "homeboy makes good."  Once again, he has surrounded himself with top-notch instrumentalists and singers that can bring everything from his bluesy rockers to his tender ballads to life with accuracy and affectation. The band is good and not overly flashy, yet more than adequately providing the backdrop that keeps James Taylor in the center spotlight.  For example, Arnold McCuller's powerful solo vocal performance during his fifteen minutes in the sun drew some of the largest audience reactions of the night.  It enhanced, however, rather than distracted from the main attraction.  It's always that way with Taylor.  He's happy to share the stage with musicians he respects, and he goes to great length to show camaraderie with his fellow bandmates on stage.  

The James Taylor formula, if it's fair to call it such, is a simple one.  He acts like a lanky goof telling truly humorous anecdotes between numbers and putting a little boogie in his step when it suits him.  Furthermore, he has that rare gift of being completely genuine in his enthusiasm to be doing what he's doing.  You might say he seems born to the stage, such is his natural, happy demeanor while playing his songs.  And he has a lot of them.  With fifteen albums to his credit, not counting greatest hits and live albums, he has hundreds of songs to perform.  Being hard-pressed to play them all, he still manages to give the people what they want.  Fans were treated to such old classics as "Carolina on My Mind," "Shower the People," "You've Got a Friend," "Mexico," "Steamroller," and "Sweet Baby James," as well as more recent hits, "Little More Time with You," "Jump Up Behind Me," and "Another Day." Each was played with James Taylor's gifted immediacy.  For someone who has sung "Fire and Rain" thousands of times, he still sounds like he's suffering the tragic loss of the lover that inspired the song.  Or in the case of "Your Smiling Face," he seems happy to be singing this quintessential love song for the umpteenth time, and the audience loves every sweet minute of it, too.  Another highlight included "Belfast to Boston," which is a brand new song inspired by the unrest in Ireland.  It's basically a heartfelt and universal plea to put down the guns--everywhere--and the kind of song that sticks a lump in your throat.  
 
Curiously for someone with such a wealth of his own material, James Taylor dragged out a surprising number of cover songs.  Of course, he's always had a way of taking other people's songs and making them his own:  Carole King's "You've Got a Friend," being the most obvious example.  In addition to that signature song and "Up on a Roof" (also by Carole King), Taylor and band also played Holland, Dozier, & Holland's "How Sweet It Is (to be Loved by You)," Otis Blackwell and Jimmy Jones's "Handy Man," and two songs by Buddy Holly: "Every Day" and "Not Fade Away."  One of the best covers was a stirring version of "Wasn't That a Mighty Storm," a 1950's song by Eric Von Schmidt about the hurricane that hit Galveston, Texas, in 1900.  Nobody seemed to care that they weren't his own, and probably a vast majority of people didn't know any different.  Regardless, James Taylor's versions of these songs are well played crowd-pleasers creating appropriate amounts of intimacy and energy.  
 
Traditionally, James Taylor also pulls out a slew of his "oldies" when he goes out on a new tour. If you're a big fan of his Seventies albums like Walking Man, Gorilla, and In the Pocket, than you'd really love this show; he dragged out more than a few from those albums.  I'm not, although "Me & My Guitar" was a pleasant exception.  Last time he was on tour, if memory serves, he played more songs from Mud Slide Slim & the Blue Horizon, which  would've suited me better.  Regardless, the power of the hits far outweighed any mild discomfort from the more obscure fare.  

Some folks like to dismiss James Taylor as a bit of sap.  He'd probably be the first to admit it.  Yet, his gift for melding folk, blues, gospel, and other world-beats into his pleasant signature pop sound is without peer.  He's an exceptional songwriter, recovering addict survivor, and no mere Seventies dinosaur, as his recent album and this sold-out tour date proves.  If James Taylor is an institution of distinctively American music right at home with mother's apple pie, then I'm glad I had a slice.  
 
By Steven Stuart Baldwin 
  
  Set list: 
  Wandering (Gorilla) 
  Another Day (Hourglass) 
  Daddy's All Gone (In the Pocket) 
  Every Day (That's Why I'm Here) 
  Wasn't That a Mighty Storm 
  I Was a Fool to Care (Gorilla) 
  Little More Time with You (Hourglass) 
  Jump Up Behind Me (Hourglass) 
  Carolina on My Mind (James Taylor - Apple Album) 
  Your Smiling Face (JT) 
  Shower the People (In the Pocket) 
  How Sweet It Is (to be Loved by You) (Gorilla) 
  (Intermission) 
  Fire and Rain (Sweet Baby James 
  Belfast to Boston (New!)  
  Me & My Guitar (Walking Man 
  (I've Got to) Stop Thinkin' ‘Bout That (New Moon Shine 
  Don't Let Me Be Lonely Tonight (One Man Dog 
  Handy Man (JT 
  You've Got a Friend (Mud Slide Slim & The Blue Horizon 
  Up on the Roof (Flag 
  Mexico (Gorilla) 
  Steamroller (Sweet Baby James) 
  (Encores) 
  Shed a Little Light (New Moon Shine) 
  Not Fade Away 
  You Can Close Your Eyes (Mud Slide Slim & The Blue Horizon) 
  Sweet Baby James (Sweet Baby James)