The Phantom Tollbooth
 

Pivot Clowj
Artist: Pivot Clowj
Label: Flaming Fish Music
Length: 14 tracks / 63:54 minutes

Flaming Fish searches far and wide to find the best in edgy electronic and industrial music made by Christians. I generally find its offerings highly evocative. This one, however, falls short of the label's normal caliber of artist.
 
Pivot Clowj is a duo from Orange County, California, who are able to pack an expansive musical array under the industrial-electronica umbrella. With a broad arsenal of equipment and instrumentation, much of it home-made, they cover a lot of ground. This album ranges from highly danceable synth-pop to haunting high-tech brooding.
 
Overall, the lyrics are not overwhelmingly striking, but they certainly resonate with human experience. I found "Me Minus You" particularly meaningful because it speaks thoughtfully of breakdown in relationship, an all too frequent circumstance in this world. Pivot Clowj's strength is not in imagery so much as in narrative, be it about life situations, imagined conversations, or internal thought processes.
 
The main stumbling block here seems to be a lack of passion. The sweet irony that draws me to electronica and industrial is its ability to reach deep into my humanity. Pivot Clowj does not appear to have latched onto this quality.
 
Melody lines drone on, often consisting of just two pitches. Vocals do not generally sound as though they are invested with much emotion. Songs go on for too long, using the same loops, beating the life out of themselves by excessive repetition. Most tracks do not suffer from all these problems simultaneously, but they all seem to leave listeners feeling a little hollow.
 
The opening number, "Only," presages the rest of the album. Its progressive buildup is promising, but it leaves off before reaching a satisfactory climax. It features one of the strongest vocals of the CD, musically speaking, but even that barely registers a real heartbeat. The lyrics are suited well to the mood, speaking longingly of a transformation that only God in love can bring.
 
One of the stronger cuts, "Love in vain," is a well-developed, danceable song, with enough sonic variation to keep me interested. Yet it still can stand to be cut by a minute and a half. The lack of melody is tolerable because of the instrumental strength, and because it suits the lyrical theme of interpersonal alienation.
 
Some tracks are downright annoying, generally due to maddening loops. A few just seem pointless and uninteresting. But one standout piece, the last track on the album, demonstrates that this band need not fall prey to the ills that plague much of the rest of their music. This song, "Mind on a String," is a live recording of voice and piano, and it pulls off quite well what drum machines and sequencers fail to do. It draws on the heart of the listener, with a strong yet quirky melody and chord structure.
 
If these guys can incorporate more of what makes "Mind on a String" succeed into the rest of their work, they will be quite a prize in the Flaming Fish lineup.

Titi Ala'ilima (6/24/99)