The Phantom Tollbooth

Back from Nowhere - Radio Special Disk - The Singles
Artist:  Polarboy
Label: Rustproof Records / Pamplin Music Distribution
Time: 18 tracks / 7 songs in various formats

Polarboy occupy a space on the musical map somewhere between Collective Soul, Counting Crows, Hootie & the Blowfish, Third Day, Vigilantes of Love, and The Monkeys (yes, there is a common thread there...). They are also gratefully unique enough that none of these influences slap you upside the ears. Creating their own sound by melding these divergent influences into an accessible pop-rock format, they are now poised to be the next Big Thing. And if the marketers keep plugging away, they certainly could prove to be. In this case, being the next Big Thing would be a good thing.
 
This particular disk, Back from Nowhere - Radio Special Disk - The Singles, was clearly constructed for radio promotion. It contains eighteen tracks representing seven different songs in various formats. Some, like their single "I'll Try," are offered in four different versions. For example, the CHR mix, Rock mix, and then both of these mixes with identical band intros. Other songs, however, are offered in fewer formats, and one, "Four Leaf Clover," is only offered once. All seven tracks originally come from the Back from Nowhere album, which, given the strength of these songs, must be quite enjoyable.  Whatever the format, all of these songs are ready for repeated radio play.
 
To these ears, the different versions sound more or less the same, and no indication is made which versions, if any, are in fact the originals. Regardless, there's not a loser in the bunch. All of these songs have a great sound that would be right at home on the appropriate radio
stations, resulting in singing-along and toe-tapping pleasure. Due to the repetitive nature of this offering, however, a wise consumer would be better off picking up the Back from Nowhere CD first. This Radio Special Disk is more of a fan curio than a must-have collector's item, except for those afficionados who crave everything by a band or alternate song versions.
 
Polarboy's real strengths lie in a few areas. Firstly, the lead-singer, Pol, has an incredible voice with a decent range and pleasant appeal. It's not overly distinctive, but he uses it effectively and interestingly, nonetheless.
 
Secondly, the band has written some fine lyrics that seem geared primarily for the youth group or college set, but with the same care and surprising maturity that Jars of Clay demonstrates. For example, "Do You Think" is a clever song conjuring Adam's pain at losing Eve late in his life. Additionally, the lyrics to "I'll Try" are not up to Bill Mallonee/Mark Heard standards, yet offer a commendable plea to God to help avoid the mistakes of the "music business":

        Run away my dove, run away my dove
        Getting easier to push and easy to shove
        Easier still is learning to love
        Run Away, run away my dove
        Take away my shame, all my shame
        Music business about nothing but fame
        As temptation calls my name
        Take away, take away my shame
        And I'll try to make it through
        The darkness has reached for me
        But You'll lift me up out from the deep, deep beneath
 
Whether such a statement is incongruous with the seemingly strong marketing efforts to push this band into the public ear is up to the listener to determine. The sentiment, however, is well articulated. My favorite lines are from "Nickels for Green Eyed Girls":

         Pocket full of gold
         Things which replace my soul
         Those things will fade away
         You need to save what you get
         You need to give me what you got
         I know that college was not for me
         I said I like the education
         I just didn't like the fees.

Anyone paying student loans regrettably relates.
 
Lastly, the overall upbeat sound the band generates is easy on ears accustomed to rock radio: both effectively energetic and pleasantly emotional without being either sappy or silly. Can God use another band of this particular format to bring praise to His name and encourage His saints? The evidence in these songs suggests absolutely.

By Steven Stuart Baldwin (10/27/98)
 
  (The actual album would rate higher)